The following is intended as a truly non-politcal, non-partisan observation, which is equally disturbed by the same displays from both "sides of the aisle"... please don't take it as anti or pro war or right or left wing and flame at me in comments - I have thoroughly tired of debating my views, since only those whose minds are as equally made up as mine participate in the conversation, and neither of us are going to convince each other any time soon. I am feeling very, very distraught about the most recent developments overseas. I specifically speak here of the news story yesterday about a pregnant Iraqi shot and killed by American troops during a tragic misunderstanding at a roadblock.
http://apnews.excite.com/article/20060601/D8HV5I8G0.html
This comes on top of the possible slaughter last fall in the village of Haditha (just currently coming to light through an investigation), as well every bit of anger, rage, and raw emotion feeding into violence that already existed.
I'm feeling distraught because, regardless of anyone's political belief about whether US troops should be in Iraq or what they should be doing, there can be no doubt that it is becoming more toxic by the minute to be in the US armed forces and serving in the middle east. Serving in the military is one job that I could never do myself; I have often thought about that fact, and how much more deserving our military is of
real respect, concern, and care, more than those who politicize the troops to serve
either side of the war debate actually afford them. It is so depressing to see the extremists of both sides abuse those people who serve in the military for politics, whether it is the horrifying display of someone choosing military barracks or a cemetery and military funeral (yes, this has actually happened... again and again...) to hold a demonstration against the war, or the equally horrifying display of people using blind, blanket "you don't support our troops" accusations against those who select and craft their show of objection in the most respectful and cautious of ways. Here in the U.S., we spend so much time on the outskirts of the issue that it seems we can't meet in the middle, even on Memorial Day, to just focus on how fortunate we are to have these people do for us what we can't do for ourselves. I did not see a single Memorial Day rememberance that was not abused and politicized to either praise or condemn the war.
And that's what we're doing to them at home. While in the middle east, they are experiencing all the worst parts of the same stereotyping and bigotry that contributed to the root problems, and which we spend so much of our effort here in the U.S. battling against and struggling with. The brother of the killed pregnant woman is quoted in the article saying "God take revenge on the Americans and those who brought them here." In that sentence is the language that shows the issue... the man has been charged by such sorrow, anger, and rage, that he has fallen under the blindfold of the stereotyping bigot... he didn't say he wanted revenge against the person responsible, he said he wanted "revenge on the Americans." Certainly, sympathize with his heartbreak, and allow him that anyone might say anything in the heat of that passion. But, to be fair, put the same situation in other contexts you can better understand. Imagine this version:
A caucasian man is driving his sister to the hospital, and cuts through an area of the city through which he wouldn't otherwise drive at fast speeds with little slowing down. After tearing down one particular street bearing the home of an African- American gang leader, thugs see the car barreling down the road and shout warnings that it turn around (imagining it to be a drive-by), and when it doesn't, they fire what they describe as warning shots to disable the vehicle, but instead shoot and kill the pregnant woman. Later, in the press, the brother is quoted as saying "God take revenge on the black people and those who put them into this impoverished neighborhood." I've framed it with the racial choices (it could be vice-versa in races too, or even other races than Caucasion and African-American, but I chose that one because its racial charge is already so familiar to us) because it is a context we can relate to in America. The fundmental issue at the end is this... the man is so enraged with grief that he cannot see that this incident and others that involve African-Americans in urban areas are not automatically indicitive of the larger wholes, nor are they automatically limiting to the population subsets. Being African-American does not mean you live in the bricks, nor does living in the bricks mean you are a violent felon, nor certainly does it mean that being African-American makes you a violent felon... so it sounds absurd to want revenge on the whole of the race for the actions of one.
But somehow this is tolerated, and even encouraged, by this mindset we see again and again. An American soldier engaged in a fatal shooting... so all Americans are deserving of the revenge? It is more and more tragic because there have been a few other examples (Abu Gharib, Haditha, etc.) that make the perpetrator of the generalization feel even more justified... but again, even a hundred examples... or a
thousand examples... in a total class size of 1.4 million (size of the total U.S. active duty armed forces - not including 1.3 million in reserves) does NOT justify making a generalization about the entire class that they are all deserving of revenge... and ESPECIALLY not in a class size of 281,422,000 (Americans, using the U.S. definition of the word, which is what the man intended). Ironically, encased in this discussion is the temptation (that
must be quashed!) to retaliate with an equally poor generalization: that somehow all Islamic believers stereotype Americans (violent fundamentalists don't make up a large enough sample size to warrant the generalization, nor even do people who would make a statement similar to that one I cited from the article).
And so, armed with this generalization that all Americans (and especially military) are deserving of "revenge", on come more loonies wearing explosives or firing guns. And it all keeps on perpetuating.
Even though there are over a million of them, in some ways, being a U.S. soldier today has got to be one of the most lonely feelings in the world, like everyone is out to get you... ...or would that be another unsubstantiated generalization?